Ruck vs Weighted Vest? Aww Ruck it…

Last update:

Doing crazy workouts with weight strapped to your body is cool.

Running with something loading you down is cool.

Heck, walking with a heavy load dangling from your back or shoulders is cool.

Is there a “best” weight-bearing apparatus to slip on to enable you to do all of these cool things?

Enter the ruck vs weighted vest debate!

Tackling Murph with a vest for the first time was a…humbling experience.

Tackling Chad 1000x in a heavy ruck for the first time…may have been harder.

Today, I want to share my experiences with rucks and weighted vests and to tally the final score of the ruck vs weighted vest throwdown.

(hint: it was a nail-biter; both are excellent in their own ways!)

Afterwards, you’ll know what to do when your own bodyweight just isn’t enough for the workouts and challenges you have in mind!

What is a Ruck?

You ever seen one of those specials on the Discovery Channel on US Army Ranger training? You remember how those half-dead, half-emaciated guys were hauling around those YUGE bags on their backs?

Yeah, those are rucksacks (rucks). This is one I travel with when I want to get a ruck in while on the road.

Rucks have their origins in just about every Western military. German, Brit, and US elite infantry units have all heavily (ha!) employed the use of rucks throughout history.

Not every ruck is designed to carry a military campaign’s worth of provisions and munitions in it, though. Rucks come in a variety of sizes, including those on the “smaller” side.

Is there anything consistent between rucks? 

Sure. A ruck is always going to be tough to carry. 

You’re also always going to get a great workout from carrying one.

You can also count on your ruck to hold up through just about anything. If you find yourself inspired to take up rucking and want to save a few bucks by borrowing your kid’s backpack…just don’t.

What are Rucks Used For?

As Rambo and his Special Forces friends have shown us, rucks were historically used by infantry soldiers to haul a lot of equipment. Oftentimes trekking long distances, rucks are carefully designed to support large loads while efficiently distributing the weight around the body.